In my experience, only one spot avoided this trap: La Bouchee on Old Brompton Road. (Near the Lycee Francais, long a favourite of the French expat community.) A new trend in gastropub-style French spots is following La Bouchee, offering short menus of traditional classics, well-prepared and pleasantly plated, on scrubbed wooden tables in casual, simple rooms.
Proof point No. 1: Antidote. It's a bare-bones wine bar down a quiet lane just off Carnaby Street. Fully staffed by French expats and introduced to me by the new French account executive at one of my agencies, it has an authenticity that reminds me of cozy spots we discovered on holiday in Burgundy.
The menu is seasonal and heavy on imported, regional French ingredients. I started with scallops with chestnuts and confit chicken wing; the nuts were a surprising but excellent match with the shellfish. On to Gascony black pork with apricots and soft polenta. The pork was a bit fatty for my taste ... I suspect it should have been slow cooked longer to render it out ... but the combo of sharp, sweet fruit with smooth, buttery starch was well-judged. Dessert was a dark chocolate mousse in decidedly un-gourmet proportions; so rich I left half of one of the two hefty quenelles.
They're quite proud of their wine list here, which is heavy on organics and small vineyards. We let the wine waiter recommend something interesting and ended up with one of those classic French bottles that pairs well with the food but isn't very palatable on its own. (We should have known what we were in for when the wine list said: "This wine will not leave you indifferent.") The white Julien Courtois "Originel", from Solonge in the Loire Valley was 80% menu pineau, 20% romorantin, and so musky with farmyard scents we had to ask the waiter if it was corked. Had he tasted it? Yes, and it was as it should be. I thought he was pulling one over on us until I tasted it with the pork. Excellent. But I wouldn't do it again. I want wine that's more than a condiment.
Prices are £6 to £8 for starters and £13 to £18 for mains, which is cheaper than the more traditional French menus though certainly not a steal. A quirky, quality spot in a part of town that's increasingly dominated by chains.
Proof point No. 2: The Green Man & French Horn on St. Martins Lane. Like Antidote, this is a one-of-a-kind spot in a high traffic tourist area awash with chain restaurants. It shares the casual feel, organics-heavy wine list and the authentic French approach. (Though the angle here is that it's all specifically about the Loire Valley.) In fact, they're so close in style you could be forgiven for thinking they share ownership. No. The Man & Horn does have a sister restaurant, but it's nearby Terroirs, the experiment in French tapas we visited in April.
If you're eating, rather than just out for a good by-the-glass wine list with some nibbles, this is a more fulfilling experience than Terroirs. Though probably a bit more expensive, and less congenial, than Antidote. While both cram as many tables as they can into a small space, The Man & Horn squishes the most. Five of us were around a table that would have been a bit cramped even for four, jammed against a wall and across from the stairs to the wine cellar.
The food here has a narrow edge on Antidote, however. My Jerusalem artichoke soup managed to be both delicate and full flavoured, while the pork rillette brought grins of deep satisfaction to the boys at the table. No wine experimentation with this lunch: we went for a pleasingly floral Sancerre that worked beautifully with both the starters and an amazing poached pear, which sat on a pool of salted carmel and had been injected with cream in the cavity left when it had been cored which didn't reveal itself until you plunged your spoon in. A neat trick. In between, there was a rich and hearty red (the label of which escaped my notice), partridge for some and beef for others. Like sister restaurant Terroirs, this place has a deeply-local French wine list with a lot of options by the glass or carafe.
Both Antidote and The Green Man & French Horn are welcome additions to the restaurant scene in London. We have plenty of haut cuisine, and plenty of spots that feel like affluent Parisian bistros. But not the kind of homely places I'd enjoyed in the countryside. These deliver on that simpler ethos, though when you emerge you'll have a trudge back to the tube rather than a saunter along some lovely canal. C'est la vie.
If you're eating, rather than just out for a good by-the-glass wine list with some nibbles, this is a more fulfilling experience than Terroirs. Though probably a bit more expensive, and less congenial, than Antidote. While both cram as many tables as they can into a small space, The Man & Horn squishes the most. Five of us were around a table that would have been a bit cramped even for four, jammed against a wall and across from the stairs to the wine cellar.
The food here has a narrow edge on Antidote, however. My Jerusalem artichoke soup managed to be both delicate and full flavoured, while the pork rillette brought grins of deep satisfaction to the boys at the table. No wine experimentation with this lunch: we went for a pleasingly floral Sancerre that worked beautifully with both the starters and an amazing poached pear, which sat on a pool of salted carmel and had been injected with cream in the cavity left when it had been cored which didn't reveal itself until you plunged your spoon in. A neat trick. In between, there was a rich and hearty red (the label of which escaped my notice), partridge for some and beef for others. Like sister restaurant Terroirs, this place has a deeply-local French wine list with a lot of options by the glass or carafe.
Both Antidote and The Green Man & French Horn are welcome additions to the restaurant scene in London. We have plenty of haut cuisine, and plenty of spots that feel like affluent Parisian bistros. But not the kind of homely places I'd enjoyed in the countryside. These deliver on that simpler ethos, though when you emerge you'll have a trudge back to the tube rather than a saunter along some lovely canal. C'est la vie.